Built Between Meetings

Dayforce CPO and veteran public company director Amy Cappellanti-Wolf explains why the strongest CEO-board relationships depend on context, candor and productive tension, and why trust can’t be manufactured in a crisis.
Amy Cappellanti-Wolf
Source: Amy Cappellanti-Wolf

Directors are typically in the room together four to six times a year. In between, the business changes, often dramatically, yet directors are still expected to make the company’s highest-stakes calls. Whether they’re ready depends largely on what happens in the gaps: how much context management shares, how early the bad news shows up, and how honestly both sides are willing to argue.

Amy Cappellanti-Wolf has seen this from both sides. As EVP and chief people officer at Dayforce, and previously CHRO at Cohesity and Symantec, with earlier leadership roles at Cisco and Disney, she has helped steer companies through major transformation. She has also seen how that change looks from the boardroom, having served on the boards of Softchoice, where she chaired the compensation committee, and D-Wave Quantum. In the following interview, she explains why boards should question the strategy as hard as they track its execution, how to tell productive tension from dysfunction, and why trust that isn’t built in calm periods can’t be built during a crisis.

You’ve experienced major organizational change from the C-suite and now from the boardroom. What do you understand about the CEO-board relationship today that you didn’t fully appreciate as an operator?

As an operator, I understood the importance of keeping the board informed and aligned. What I appreciate more deeply as a director is the difference between providing information and creating real understanding.

Directors typically attend four to six board meetings a year, along with committee meetings. They’re not in the business every day, nor should they be. Yet they’re expected to exercise sound judgment on some of the company’s most consequential decisions.

That’s why the CEO’s responsibility extends well beyond formal board meetings. Regular dialogue, context along the way, and candor about emerging challenges are essential, particularly during periods of significant change.

The best CEO-board relationships are built between meetings, not just during them.

What are boards still not asking their CEOs often enough right now?

Boards can become so focused on whether management is delivering against the strategy that they spend too little time questioning whether it’s still the right strategy.

Technology, competitive dynamics, and business models are changing faster than traditional planning cycles. What’s most likely to disrupt our business? Are we investing in areas that will still matter three years from now? And are we moving quickly enough to adapt?

AI is a good example. The discussion needs to go beyond adoption, productivity, and risk mitigation to how AI could reshape the business model, customer expectations, competitive advantage, and how work gets done.

Boards should also challenge whether the organization has the leadership, capabilities, and capacity to execute the strategy. A sound strategy means little if the organization isn’t equipped to deliver it.

What’s one question a board can ask that reveals a great deal about whether a CEO and leadership team are truly prepared for what’s ahead?

“What assumptions are we making about our ability to execute this strategy, and which ones concern you most?”

It’s a simple question, but it reveals how well leadership understands both the opportunities and vulnerabilities facing the business.

Strong leadership teams can articulate where they’re placing bets, what could disrupt their plans, and how they’re preparing for different scenarios. They also recognize that the capabilities and competitive advantages that got them here may not be what they need going forward.

I’d pay close attention to how the team responds. Is there healthy debate? Are they willing to challenge their own assumptions? Can they distinguish between what they know and what they’re still trying to figure out?

Preparedness isn’t about having every answer. It’s about knowing where you’re vulnerable and having the discipline and agility to respond before you’re forced to.

Boards spend a lot of time on financial performance. What should they be probing beyond the traditional metrics to understand the underlying health and readiness of the business?

They’re not necessarily the same thing.

I’d look at four areas.

First, competitive relevance. Are we gaining or losing ground with customers? Are their expectations changing faster than our ability to respond?

Second, the quality of growth. Are we building sustainable value, or relying on short-term actions that could compromise future performance? Cost discipline matters, but so does knowing when you’re underinvesting in innovation and critical capabilities.

Third, execution and agility. How quickly can the organization turn strategy into action? Are decisions being made at the right levels, or is complexity slowing us down?

And finally, leadership and culture. Are leaders surfacing risks early, challenging conventional thinking, and holding themselves accountable for both results and behaviors?

Financial results tell you what’s happened. These indicators help boards understand whether the business is positioned to sustain and improve performance.

How should boards evaluate whether a company is genuinely prepared for transformation, not just whether management has a plan? And what should CEOs be bringing to that conversation early, even when the picture is still incomplete?

Organizations often underestimate the demands of driving change while running the business. That’s where leadership capacity, clear priorities, and execution discipline become critical.

Boards should challenge whether management has translated the strategy into real changes in how the company operates. What work needs to change? Which capabilities need to be built or acquired? What are we prepared to stop doing? And how will we know the transformation is actually working?

CEOs shouldn’t wait until every detail is resolved before engaging the board. Bring directors into the difficult conversations early, including the trade-offs, risks, and decisions still taking shape.

A good plan tells you where you’re going. Readiness tells you whether you can get there.

Culture is hard to see from the boardroom and hard to fully convey from the C-suite. What should boards ask, and what should CEOs be doing, to be sure the culture described is the culture employees actually experience?

I’d start with a more provocative question: Are boards seeing the culture that actually exists, or the culture management wants them to see?

Culture isn’t what an organization says it values. It’s what gets reinforced, rewarded, and tolerated. Some of the greatest cultural risks can exist in high-performing parts of the business, where strong results mask poor leadership behaviors.

Boards need to look beyond aggregate engagement scores. Where are employee experiences materially different? What are attrition and trust trends telling us? Do employees feel safe raising concerns? And perhaps the most uncomfortable question: Who are we allowing to succeed despite behaviors that undermine the culture we claim to value?

CEOs need to create an environment where bad news travels as quickly as good news, and where leaders are accountable for both what they deliver and how they deliver it. Boards also benefit from structured opportunities to hear directly from leaders beyond the CEO.

The real test of culture isn’t how an organization behaves when things are going well. It’s what happens when its values become inconvenient.

With AI moving quickly, what belongs at the board level versus what’s a management question? How should directors and CEOs each be thinking about judgment, accountability and governance rather than the technology itself?

Boards risk becoming very good at governing the risks of AI while missing the bigger question of how AI will fundamentally change the economics and competitiveness of the business.

AI is changing business models, customer expectations, decision-making, and how work gets done. That makes it a strategic governance issue, not simply a technology initiative.

The board’s responsibility is to challenge whether management has a clear AI strategy and understands the implications for the business. Where will AI create competitive advantage? What decisions should remain human-led? How are we measuring value creation and preparing the organization for a different operating model?

Management owns execution: prioritizing investments, redesigning work, building capabilities, and driving adoption. Directors don’t need to be technologists, but they do need enough AI fluency to challenge management’s assumptions and distinguish meaningful transformation from experimentation that isn’t delivering value.

Governance also needs to extend beyond privacy, security, and responsible use to decision rights, human oversight, and accountability for outcomes.

AI may change how decisions are informed and work gets done, but it doesn’t change who is accountable. That responsibility remains with people.

What does productive tension between a CEO and board actually look like in practice, and how can each side tell healthy challenge from a relationship becoming dysfunctional?

A certain amount of tension between a CEO and the board is healthy—and necessary. Frankly, if every board meeting ends in agreement without meaningful debate, I’d question whether the board is doing its job.

Good directors challenge assumptions, bring different perspectives, and aren’t afraid to ask uncomfortable questions. Strong CEOs don’t interpret every challenge as a vote of no confidence. They recognize that constructive debate leads to better decisions.

But there’s a line between challenging management’s thinking and trying to run the business. Directors need to know when to push and when to step back.

The relationship becomes dysfunctional when disagreements turn personal, directors pursue individual agendas, decisions are repeatedly revisited without new information, or CEOs start filtering what the board hears to avoid difficult conversations.

The test is whether both sides can challenge each other openly, make a better decision, and walk away with the relationship intact.

Where do CEO-board relationships most often break down, oversharing, undersharing, boards accepting assumptions too readily, directors edging into management, and what do the strongest relationships do differently?

Undersharing is generally more damaging than oversharing, particularly when important context is missing or difficult issues surface too late. But volume isn’t the answer either. A hundred-page board deck can still leave directors without the information they actually need.

There’s also risk at both ends of the governance spectrum. Boards that accept management’s assumptions without sufficient challenge aren’t fulfilling their oversight responsibilities. Directors who become too involved in operating decisions can undermine the CEO’s authority and accountability.

The best relationships get that balance right. CEOs provide context, not just information, and engage directors regularly between meetings. Boards bring independent perspectives, challenge constructively, and respect the line between oversight and execution.

Transparency doesn’t mean sharing everything. It means exercising judgment about what the board needs to know, when it needs to know it, and why it matters.

Trust isn’t about avoiding every surprise. It’s about ensuring the board isn’t blindsided by something management knew was coming but chose not to share.

Do the best CEO-board relationships look different during a crisis or major transformation than during more stable periods?

Absolutely. The intensity of engagement changes, but the fundamentals shouldn’t.

During a crisis or major transformation, decisions move faster, the stakes are higher, and boards need more frequent communication and greater visibility into emerging risks. But directors also need to resist the temptation to cross from oversight into management, particularly when the pressure is on.

I’ve found that a crisis doesn’t necessarily change the CEO-board relationship as much as it exposes its strengths and weaknesses. You can’t manufacture trust in the middle of a crisis. It’s built through the candor, judgment, and constructive dialogue that happen when things are going well.

How should a CEO handle a director who is pushing hard in a direction the CEO believes is wrong?

I’d start by separating the concern from the proposed solution. A director may be pushing for an outcome the CEO disagrees with, but that doesn’t mean the underlying concern isn’t legitimate.

The CEO should understand what’s driving the director’s perspective, test their own assumptions, and consider whether they’re missing something. But they also need the conviction to explain their position, supported by facts and a clear understanding of the trade-offs.

Directors bring valuable experience, but they don’t have the same day-to-day context as management. That’s why the dialogue matters.

What doesn’t work is conceding to avoid conflict or dismissing the challenge because it feels like interference. It’s not about proving who’s right. It’s about getting to the best decision while respecting who is accountable for making and executing it.

What can CEOs do to make it easier for their boards to hear uncertainty, bad news, or a decision that’s still taking shape?

CEOs sometimes underestimate how much credibility they build by acknowledging what they don’t yet know.

There’s a tendency to bring boards fully formed recommendations and polished presentations. But some of the most valuable conversations happen before all the answers are clear, when directors can help challenge assumptions, consider alternatives, and identify risks.

Be explicit about what’s known, what’s assumed, and where uncertainty remains. That doesn’t signal weakness. It demonstrates judgment.

And remember, transparency is about relevance and timing, not volume. Boards don’t need every operational detail, but they do need visibility into issues that could materially affect the business.

Boards can handle uncertainty and bad news. What erodes confidence is discovering that management knew something important and waited until the options were limited to share it.

If you could give one piece of advice to boards about getting more from their CEOs, and one to CEOs about getting more from their boards, what would each be?

To boards: Challenge the assumptions behind the strategy with the same rigor you bring to financial performance. Ask what could fundamentally change the business, whether management is investing in the right capabilities, and whether the organization can execute. Your job isn’t to have all the answers. It’s to ask the questions that make management’s thinking stronger.

To CEOs: Treat your board as a strategic asset, not simply a governance obligation. Engage directors between meetings, provide context as the business evolves, and bring them into consequential conversations early enough to benefit from their perspectives. The best CEOs know how to draw on the collective experience of their boards without giving up accountability for running the business.

MORE LIKE THIS

Get the Corporate Board Member Newsletter

Timely analysis and practical perspective on the governance, risk and oversight issues shaping today’s board agendas.

UPCOMING EVENTS

Directors Forum